You MUST pay the rent! I can't pay the rent!
It is more expensive to be poor than it is to be middle
class or higher. The refugees I've worked with have to pay a $300 deposit for
electricity -- maybe two months' worth. For rent, they pay three months of rent
(a quarter of a year!) upfront, and/or have a co-signer (who essentially has to
share (and risk) their own credit score) to be eligible to rent an apartment.
It makes sense: these people are living on the edge of solvency and we have no
idea what they understand, what their work ethic is, whether the decisions made
are financially sound. It is a risk to rent to them, or to start ongoing
service. For refugees, the agencies help build the trust, as they can talk with
property companies and explain that the government will pay the first three
months of rent, and they are going to make sure the families don't fail. They
also have (had) some funds to cover the early months of utilities, and phone,
and other bills for the first few months.
Trust is essential. Building credit is essentially a way of publicly
building trust. Many of us are able to lend our kids a measure of trust right
at first. My kids have a credit card in their name that is tied to my credit
card...and my credit. My parents did the same for me. That trust means that
they didn’t have to pay as much to get apartments set up. I was also able to
help them with early jobs, or they got them through college, further building a
record of responsibility. (And it is worth noting that we were able to afford college
thanks to my dad, so the generations work together). When the kids got first
apartments and first utilities, if they needed it, we could help them with
security deposits if their credit-built-on-our-credit wasn't enough.
Refugees just arrived -- they have no record. That earlier
post where AI tried to "verify" their identity by asking them to
identify which information they have been associated with them through publicly
available sources is an example of what that newness is like. My kids would
likely not had that problem, as there is an American digital record for them
already, and certainly associated with us.
Furthermore, it isn’t just money. It is also time. At the
point when my kids “needed” a car, we helped them so that they didn’t have to spend
valuable time on the bus.
It makes me wonder about people who don't have either an
agency or parents who can help. It is so much more expensive to set yourself up
in this world if you don't already have credit or someone to share theirs with
you. Experian
says that about 71% of Americans have a good or better credit score,
but that means that 29% do not. And for that 29% life is much more expensive,
in terms of both time and money. I’m not commenting on whether this is right or
wrong, but just noting that we live in very different worlds.
Comments
Post a Comment